The UK's Largest Customer Review Website for the Property Industry

No Image Available

Sheffield, S1

3.2/5, 12 Reviews
70% Recommended

60% letting valuation accuracy

57% letting fee satisfaction

Contact Us
No Description Found
"Good start, awful..."

Share On :  FacebookTwitter

1 Star Review

By : 'Lyndon B'
Services : Letting(I am a Landlord / Landlady)
Would you recommend ? : No
Postcode : S6

18 Sept 2025
People found this helpful0

This review is to support Landlords wanting to use Haybrooks to their property, I try and take time and effort to factually lay out experiences with companies and hope this supports decision making those considering Haybrooks services in the future; Initially Haybrooks appeared to be a slick company, they opened up with a reasonable rental price the area and quickly the property. Communication was prompt and effective, thankfully little was required due to renovating before letting so all goods were and the property was recently decorated. We first ran into issues when Haybrooks where they were required to do work on the property, or the tenants wished to have something replaced or checked. Responses could take over a week and Haybrooks team were often not answering to resolve this issues. Offering little to assure the tenants, they would contact myself and ask things to be done having been ignored by Haybrooks or having been left without answers. There are a plethora of small frustrating problems to large and concerning issues that can be evidenced, here is a small sample below that we had; - A replacement dishwasher that was never ordered, took nearly 3 months to replace and they charged us without having done the work. We recovered the money and had to replace ourselves -They had to ask us the tenants had moved out, and were not aware whether they were still in the property or not -Allowed the contract to lapse without reviewing, this ended with late payments (resolved) -Several late payments, longest being 8 days fron the expected pay date -We have requested, with the most recent tenants, and what is contractually expected, that they complete onsite, inperson, checks on the property, they have been unable to send a single report or image back to me suggesting this work has been completed -Charging us several services when changing tenants, stating it was done, not offering evidence, and much later only returning the money when I had requested review by the SpiceHart complaints team, whoninvestigates and found the work not to have been completed -New smoke alarms were causing an issue, they would not go to view or sort them, these appear to be subsequently disconnected when I have gone to do other work in the property in the absence of a Haybrooks service manager Their care and attention is negligent at best. Their service team and managers do little to help and do not appear to communicate with each other. A good example of this is 6 months after the dishwasher issue, I was called to see and when it was suitable to fit the dishwasher. This is 3 months after ringing and emailing them to our money they had taken due to the work not having even been completed. They chronically say all the right things, but then offer no action. We have made multiple complaints to their branch managers and SpiceHart (their parent company) which ended with apologies, returned money and further promises. Again, the promises have not come to fruition. We have been told that these are caused by "staffing issues" and "they will perform the requested checks", but as aforementioned, they have not done as they have stated, and we have still had to pay the full fee what they in particular have agreed throughout as inadequate services. (Emails sent to us and recorded conversations with SpiceHart complaints team). It has been more stressful dealing with Haybrooks than running the property myself. I am glad and genuinely relieved to have separated from them today as I feel that they have, since the start, only successfully managed to get tenants in quickly and frustratingly failed at every other management job and opportunity. On reflection, this is something you can pay a seperate company without paying a monthly %. I have very little good to say about this service and their team. I hope they reflect as professionals on how poorly they have delivered. I will to pursue my complaints and escalate as required because I don't think what has happened to me is fair and should happen to anyone . Landlords who are bothered about the health of their property, and the wellbeing of their tenants, should avoid using their services.


Comments on Agent Fees

Fees covered them doing absolutely nothing and answering the phone late enough, sometimes weeks, so that the urgent work had already be completed for safety reasons.

Was this helpful?:

Agent Response / Add a Comment

You can use this form to reply to the above review or a displayed comment on the above review.

Your name*

Your email (not displayed)*

Comment*

Upload your files

Please upload file with .jpg, .jpeg or .pdf format

  Please tick the box if you work for this firm

Note: Your comment will not be activated until you click on the link in an email sent to your address as submitted in the form above. By clicking on Submit Comment you agree to receive an activation email from allAgents.

Latest Reviews
Performance Statistics
ServicesValuationFeesMin Price of property reviewedMax Price of property reviewed
Letting60%57.00%£450£895
Address

Haybrook
43-45 Church StreetSheffield, West Yourksire
S1 2GL
0114 446 9381

Services offered
  • Sales
  • Lettings
  • Block Management
  • Surveys
  • Conveyancing
  • Mortgage Advice
Advertise on
  • ?Relocation Agent Network
  • ?National Homes Network
  • ?Move With Us
  • allAgents Portal
  • OnTheMarket
  • ?Rightmove
  • ?Zoopla
Social Media
TwitterEmail
Latest Properties

No Property Found

No Property Found
Haybrook Branches (View All 13)
Good start, awful ...

Share On :  FacebookTwitter

1 Star Review

By : 'Lyndon'
Services : 1
Would you recommend ? : No
Postcode : S6

18 Sept 2025
People found this helpful

This review is to support Landlords wanting to use Haybrooks to their property, I try and take time and effort to factually lay out experiences with companies and hope this supports decision making those considering Haybrooks services in the future; Initially Haybrooks appeared to be a slick... Read Full Review


Comments on Agent Fees

Fees covered them doing absolutely nothing and answering the phone late enough, sometimes weeks, so that the urgent work had already be completed for safety reasons.

Comments (0)Was this helpful?:
Good start, awful ...

Share On :  FacebookTwitter

1 Star Review

By : 'Lyndon'
Services : 1
Would you recommend ? : No
Postcode : S6

18 Sept 2025
People found this helpful

This review is to support Landlords wanting to use Haybrooks to their property, I try and take time and effort to factually lay out experiences with companies and hope this supports decision making those considering Haybrooks services in the future; Initially Haybrooks appeared to be a slick... Read Full Review


Comments on Agent Fees

Fees covered them doing absolutely nothing and answering the phone late enough, sometimes weeks, so that the urgent work had already be completed for safety reasons.

Comments (0)Was this helpful?:
Disapponted ...

Share On :  FacebookTwitter

1 Star Review

By : 'Aerojex'
Services : Letting (As a Owner)
Would you recommend ? : Yes

27 Jan 2022
People found this helpful1

I used Haybrook Lettings to find tenants for my property in Sheffield in December 2020. I paid Haybrooks for the full Management so that I didnt have any contact with the tenants. Haybrooks found me the tenants which are Romanian. The tenants reported a problem with water coming through the kitchen ... Read Full Review

Comments (0)Was this helpful?:
Haybrook Sheffield - great ...

Share On :  FacebookTwitter

5 Star Review
UserName

By : 'Rachael'
Services : Letting (As a Tenant)
Rent PCM : £600
Would you recommend ? : Yes
Postcode : DN8

25 Oct 2019
People found this helpful0

We are really happy with the service so far from Haybrook. We are new to the renting scene as we've lived in military housing for years so we were a bit clueless. Chloe really talked us through it and whenever we have had queries we've got a prompt response via email from Sharon even... Read Full Review

Comments (0)Was this helpful?:
Highly ...

Share On :  FacebookTwitter

1 Star Review

By : 'Outofpocket'
Services : Letting (As a Tenant)
Would you recommend ? : No
Postcode : S10

12 Jun 2019
People found this helpful1

This branch of yours is so not bothered it beggars belief, took out a contract on 4brick street Crookes for 6 months but decided not to move in as we realised it was not suitable, when we first took it we spent about£100 making it livable ie new curtains new shower head paint etc. When we ... Read Full Review


Comments on Agent Fees

Bad

Comments (1)Was this helpful?:

By : Katie Woodhead

13 Jun 2019

Hi Outofpocket, thanks for raising this with us. We are sorry to see that you are feeling frustrated. Please make contact with us directly at help@haybrook to enable us to fully understand your...

Review ...

Share On :  FacebookTwitter

5 Star Review
UserName

By : 'Chris'
Services : Letting (As a Owner)
Would you recommend ? : Yes
Postcode : S18

27 Nov 2018
People found this helpful0

I am very happy with the service. I was surprised that a tenant was found in as little as week. The team are very professional and curious and have kept me updated throughout the process. I have already recommended Haybrook to a friend who is looking for new... Read Full Review


Comments on Agent Fees

I found the fees reasonable with the correct cover. as Ms Owen said, It's what value you place on the running of the property.

Comments (0)Was this helpful?:
Con ...

Share On :  FacebookTwitter

1 Star Review

By : 'Todd'
Services : Letting (As a Owner)
Would you recommend ? : No
Postcode : S61

20 Sept 2018
People found this helpful0

Myself and my husband own a property in Rotherham and have chosen yourselves the take care of the rent. Shortly into the contract your staff showed they was utterly incompetent and was told to leave the property and our client alone. We have now been getting calls of our client who is having to... Read Full Review


Comments on Agent Fees

Hidden

Comments (0)Was this helpful?:
No special mentions to anyone ...

Share On :  FacebookTwitter

5 Star Review

By : 'Rich'
Services : Letting (As a Owner)
Would you recommend ? : Yes
Postcode : S6

3 Mar 2018
People found this helpful1

No special mentions to anyone in particular as everyone I have dealt with has been fabulous. I have a few properties for rent with haybrook now and will be adding more to my portfolio. Thanks for the great... Read Full Review

Comments (1)Was this helpful?:

By : ross

9 Mar 2018

Hi there, Thanks for your kind words and thank you for the 5-star feedback. Have a wonderful...

DO NOT USE THIS FIRM FOR ...

Share On :  FacebookTwitter

1 Star Review
UserName

UserName

By : 'Elizabeth'
Services : Letting (As a Owner)
Rent PCM : £550
Would you recommend ? : No
Postcode : S6

13 Jan 2018
People found this helpful0

DO NOT USE THIS FIRM FOR RENTING YOUR PROPERTY OUT. they have a management company that rips you off at every opportunity. They explain nothing then take money from the incoming rent. The insurance is pointless as they won't claim. What was my home has been totally trashed by their so... Read Full Review


Comments on Agent Fees

RIDICULOUS ...£90 A month for my house to be ruined. Ripped off with every quote. Not told about fees. Con men.

Comments (1)Was this helpful?:

By : ross

9 Mar 2018

Hi there, We apologies for the poor experience you received with us, please email in to help@haybrook.com so we can look into your experience. Thank...

Thank you to Sharon & ...

Share On :  FacebookTwitter

5 Star Review
UserName

By : 'Angie'
Services : Letting (As a Tenant)
Would you recommend ? : Yes
Postcode : S6

20 Feb 2017
People found this helpful0

Thank you to Sharon & Elle Maher for your help towards of my colleague at work. It's been wonderful to see them that they are happy and pleased the property they are... Read Full Review


Comments on Agent Fees

Friendly and approachable!!!!

Comments (1)Was this helpful?:

By : Ross

20 Feb 2017

Hi Angie, Thank you for your kind review of our Sheffield branch, we're pleased to hear your colleague had a positive experience with the branch. We will certainly pass this feedback...

Thank you Sharon and Elle ...

Share On :  FacebookTwitter

5 Star Review
UserName

By : 'Chiara'
Services : Surveying (Surveys)
Rent PCM : £895
Would you recommend ? : Yes
Postcode : S62W

8 Feb 2017
People found this helpful0

Thank you Sharon and Elle in chuch street branch for all your help you both extraordinary helpful since from our application until to the end. Thank... Read Full Review


Comments on Agent Fees

Buono

Comments (1)Was this helpful?:

By : Ross

9 Feb 2017

Hi Chiara, Thank you for your kind review of our Sheffield branch, we're pleased to hear they provided a helpful and overall extraordinary service throughout. We will pass this feedback...

jack and matt this is for u ...

Share On :  FacebookTwitter

5 Star Review

By : 'jennie'
Services : Property Management (They manage our building)
Would you recommend ? : Yes
Postcode : S66

17 Nov 2016
People found this helpful0

jack and matt this is for u ,my words cant express how grateful we are for all your hard work in letting our property,from the word go you both excelled in our expectations ,you gave us confidence in you and a five star service,the phone contact and professionalism that we have received off both of ... Read Full Review


Comments on Agent Fees

fees are resonable.

Comments (1)Was this helpful?:

By : Ross

18 Nov 2016

Hi Jennie, Thank your for your kind review of our Sheffield branch. We're pleased to hear they worked hard and exceeded your expectations. We will pass this feedback on to the...

1 - 12 of 12 items
No Staff Registered

NaN - NaN of items
No fees information available

Kindly note that legally, letting agents need to publish information about their tenancy fees, government-approved redress schemes and client money protection schemes on their website and on third party websites (on which agents are listed). For properties to lease/rent in England, agents need to keep this information up to date and precise on allAgents or specify within the property description.

Complaints Procedure



Last updated at 11/30/2, 12:00:00 AM by allAgents

Awards won by Haybrook, Sheffield S1 2GL