“I wanted to write this review in order to inform ......”
1 Star Review
Nov 14,2015
By:
'Student'
Nov 14,2015
Branch: Manchester, 147 - 151 Burton Road
Services: Lettings (as a Tenant)
Rent PCM: £280
Would you recommend?: No
Postcode: M14
Branch: Manchester, 147 - 151 Burton Road
Lettings (as a Tenant)
Rent PCM: £280
Postcode: M14
2
people found
this helpful
I wanted to write this review in order to inform students NOT to rent a property from Phillip James and go elsewhere, moving out and renting off a private landlord has affirmed my feelings that Phillip James are bloody terrible...I can only speak for the Withington Branch, but I would like to share my experiences with them.
I was one of 6 individuals who rented a room in a 6 bedroom student house in Fallowfield, Manchester.
First of all, before we moved into the property, we were promised that they were going to make improvements to the house before we moved in, this was part of the reason we were sold on the house! When we moved into the property, none of the things promised had been done, a lot of the areas had not even been cleaned, we were okay with it but on top of this, there was no microwave, bin or hoover, all things we had to request. In addition to this, the gas was not running properly for AN ENTIRE MONTH, we were aware that it had been switched off due to previous tenants not paying and the house being unoccupied for a year, but we were told that it would be sorted for the date we moved in, when we did move in, it seemed like the matter had been totally forgotten about, I had to do all my cooking in the microwave and oven for an entire month, and it was extremely lucky that the shower was electric and the heating did not need to be on at that time of year!!
I feel like the company is very disorganised....
Secondly, You are not allocated a specific member of staff, the relationship you have with them feels completely impersonal, when you call up with any issues, you are usually put through to someone you have never spoken to before, and usually have to repeat things to them that you have said several times over the phone even in the same week....
We had in incident in the house where a member suffered some mental health issues and abrubtly left the property, leaving us all liable for his rent.
I feel like the way I was spoken to about the matter was completely cold and unecessary, what happened in the house actually made me feel very low the entire christmas period last year, which was worsened by the fact I recieved an email from a member of staff on christmas eve announcing that we were liable for his rent as he had left the country. I read the email on a lovely evening spent in the pub on christmas eve which was instantly made to feel very uptight over the entire christmas period. I expressed I thought it was pretty inconsiderate to tell me something like that on christmas eve when they are a student estate agent and should be aware that it is impossible to sort out a new tenant/organise viewings with potential punters if you are students who travel back to different places over the holidays, especially christmas!! I spent boxing day and the following days putting up ads, but I soon realised I was pretty much helpless until I got back to manchester. I feel like he really should have known this all along!
When I replied to the staff member, I feel like the way he phrased things was blunt, unapoligetic and demeaning. I now have an amazing and friendly landlord who just focuses on one property and I know if the same thing had happened in my new house he would have handled the situation completely differently and atleast shown a slight bit of empathy...
FINALLY,
Our contract ended in June, however I recieved my cheque for the deposit just last week, they said they needed confirmation that we had payed all of our last bills which I can understand, but the company we were with was completely useless and was not providing us with one. In the end we recieved the deposit, the 6 of us were charged 25 pounds each for 'cleaning and replacing 2 light bulbs' I don't know how the price of that was concluded it £150 and I didn't realised tenants were liable when light bulbs blew but It didn't feel like too much so I just let it slide, on top of this though, we were charged a £30 admin fee, and £100 of the original amount we payed has miraculously dissappeared off the statement, when I emailed them requesting they break down the costs they have not responded to my email.
JUST AVOID THEM AT ALL COSTS.
I have spent time writing this review to make sure people did not make the same mistake I did.
What agent could do to change your mind?
Deposit return has not been properly explained
Attached Filesnbsp;
Comment on agent fees
Deposit return has not been properly explained
2
people found
this helpful
Was this helpful?
Yes
Although you may believe that no work was undertaken at the property prior to you moving in, I can assure you that this was not the case. Your landlord completes their own maintenance works as you are aware and they did so prior to your tenancy starting and you moving into the property in September 2014. I can assure you that the matter regarding the gas supply at the property had not been forgotten about however it did take longer to resolve than anticipated. We acted as quickly as possible with regards to resolving this matter and I believe it to have been resolved within a reasonable time frame.
As student tenants you are allocated a specific member of staff which is our student advisor. Initially, when moving into the property you dealt with Mr James Hawley who subsequently left the company and was replaced by Mr Mark Lewin. You have named Mark in your complaint specifically and you have dealt with Mark throughout the remainder of your tenancy following James leaving the company in December of last year. As I am sure you can appreciate, there are different members of staff working in various departments within our company and one person cannot satisfy all job roles. You are inevitably going to speak to different people at some point throughout your tenancy, however I believe the only other person you have had frequent communication with, particularly at the end of the tenancy is my colleague Miss Jemma Porter. I apologise you may feel as though you have had to repeat yourselves on a number of occasions however unfortunately, if Mark is not available, we will strive to resolve your issues for you therefore the need to repeat the issue you have is necessary for us to assist you.
I refute the allegation that the matter with regards to the tenant that had to vacate was dealt with coldly. We extended our sympathy to you all following the actions that occurred and attempted to help you resolve the situation as much as possible. As joint tenants, you are all equally liable for the rent at the property therefore unfortunately, with one tenant leaving, the remaining 5 tenants need to cover that 1 person's share of the rent; you are all equally liable to ensure that the rental income per calendar month is paid, as with any joint tenancy agreement. We are aware that students often return home for the Christmas period and I do not believe you were contacted out of malice. We have a duty to advise you of such obligations, the earlier you are alerted to the situation the sooner the situation can be resolved. This was simply done in an attempt to help you.
As per clause 3.12 of your signed tenancy agreement, you must provide copies of your final bills before any part of the deposit will be returned to you. You were advised of the exact cleaning required and the replacement of light bulbs. As per TDS guidelines, you are given the opportunity to dispute the charges made to the deposit however you declined to do so. As per clause 2.15 of your signed tenancy agreement, you as tenants are liable for the replacement of light bulbs throughout your tenancy. Please refer to your tenancy agreement for further clarification on this point.
I apologise that you have yet to receive a response to the email you initially sent and I will chase this up with the relevant people to ensure that the matter is brought to a close as soon as possible.
I hope this response has clarified the issues raised and has helped to explain the reasons behind our actions.
Philip James